Skip to the report

Carry it or return to it

A battery you carry gets heavier the longer you must run. A decay source does not, its mass is fixed and its output is set by half-life. Somewhere they cross, and where they cross decides what every autonomous machine on earth is built around.

Predict first

Make the robot twice as powerful. Everything it does needs double the watts. What happens to the point where a decay source becomes lighter than a battery?

The machine

What it carries

Strategy

Decay source modelled as Sr-90 at 930 W thermal per kg with 5% thermoelectric conversion, so 46.5 W electrical per kg. Source mass only, no shield, structure or conversion hardware, all of which make it worse.

The derivation

Battery mass m = P·t / e rises with duration. Decay mass m = P / p does not. Setting them equal gives t* = e / p, and P cancels. The crossover is a property of the two energy technologies, not of the machine. Figures are representative; this is a design bench, not a datasheet.

Crossover t*
—
Carried mass
—
If decay instead
—
Verdict
—
—